Martial arts myths and misconceptions

Just some of the common myths and misconceptions I have encountered over the years of martial arts exposure.

1. Black belts are experts
"Don't mess with him, he's a black belt." Ahh, I've heard this phrase countless times. Unfortunately, a belt is a very inaccurate way of measuring a person's ability, and today it is very easy to get a black belt in martial arts such as Tae Kwon Do or Karate. Most practitioners could acquire their black belts within 2-3 years of training, certainly not someone you would call experts. Besides, I have personally met many black belt holders who do not know how to hold a fist properly.

2. Bigger people move slow
Not true, unless by big you mean a couch potato, then yes. In this case it's the big-sized, muscular ones. Many heavyweight fighters move very quickly and can throw multiple punches in quick succession. Your speed depends on your muscle strength and agility, little to do with your size. But these guys tire more quickly. Just compare the build of Olympic marathon runners (endurance) and 100m sprinters (speed).

3. Size doesn't matter in a fight
People tell me that often, but in fact it is not true. Size is a very important factor in a fight. Why else would there be weight classes in boxing and MMA fights? A bigger man would be able to throw heavier punches due to their larger body mass. In a real fight, smaller person would actually be in a disadvantage. Size matters, but it is not all that matters.

4. Sparring will train you in fights
Well, a person who spars regularly would probably perform better than a person who doesn't, but sparring will do little to help you in the event of an actual street-fight. First of all, in a sparring match you are bounded by rules; no kick to groins, no hair pulling, spitting etc. In a real fight, anything goes. Secondly, in no-contact sparring you are controlling your attacks, making sure you do no damage to your opponent. To train to fight, fight to train. As Bruce Lee said, if you want to learn to swim, jump into the water. On dry land, no frame of mind is ever going to help you.

5. You could kill a person by shoving their nosebone to the brain
This is a popular one, and certainly not true. For one, just study a human skull for a second and you'll probably realize that a human nose is not made up of a bone. In fact, it is made up of a soft cartilage that would be quite impossible to penetrate the skull. An average adult cranium is actually very hard and could absorb a lot of impact, and even if the "nose bone", assuming it exists does penetrate the human skull, the brain is actually a little to deep for the bone to reach. So there you have it. It would look spectacular, but it has and will never be done.

Many others just slipped my mind. Will probably post a follow-up, maybe one on fitness myths.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Not sure where to post this but I wanted to ask if anyone has heard of National Clicks?

Can someone help me find it?

Overheard some co-workers talking about it all week but didn't have time to ask so I thought I would post it here to see if someone could help me out.

Seems to be getting alot of buzz right now.

Thanks

Anonymous said...

I LOVE that you posted the "nose-bone" myth. You have a point about the black belt thing, but it REALLY depends on the school and Martial Art being taught. It took me 5 years to get to black belt rank and apparently that was as fast as was allowed. Then a year later I met someone who said they practiced a similar style but it only took them 2 years so I was quite skeptical and a bit disheartened. She then mentioned that they never spar, despite students constantly asking to, or practice any practical form of self defense and I felt bad for her instead. Anyway, nice article and watch out for the deadly nose to brain smash!! ;)

Anything contained in, not contained in, assumed to be implied by, warranted by, excluded from being warranted by, or vaguely alluded to in this document, or any other document resembling or not resembling this document in any way, shall not be attributed to, blamed upon, or otherwise associated with the named author, any alleged author, the sender, any of the sender's friends, or any other associated company in any city, county, state, province, or country, nor shall any of the aforementioned parties be held responsible, irresponsible, accountable, discountable, or in any way involved with the aforementioned document or the presence or absence thereof.